1
00:00:01,877 --> 00:00:03,345
Previously on Elementary...
2
00:00:03,347 --> 00:00:06,029
I heard the refrigerator door
open, and then all of a sudden,
3
00:00:06,043 --> 00:00:08,428
three gunshots,
and I saw
4
00:00:08,429 --> 00:00:11,213
Jameel on the kitchen floor,
blood everywhere.
5
00:00:11,214 --> 00:00:12,604
I know you killed Jameel Clark.
6
00:00:12,628 --> 00:00:15,112
He's worked for months
to embed himself in SBK.
7
00:00:15,113 --> 00:00:16,403
An endeavor I cared more about
8
00:00:16,404 --> 00:00:18,004
before I knew he was
a cold-blooded killer.
9
00:00:18,006 --> 00:00:19,739
SBK is a ruthless drug gang.
10
00:00:21,776 --> 00:00:24,444
You want to know who killed
Jameel? SBK killed Jameel.
11
00:00:24,446 --> 00:00:26,246
You're looking for someone
who killed one person.
12
00:00:26,248 --> 00:00:28,848
SBK kills dozens
of people a year.
13
00:00:28,850 --> 00:00:30,016
I'm-a take SBK down,
14
00:00:30,018 --> 00:00:32,218
and anybody who get in my way...
15
00:00:32,220 --> 00:00:33,920
...gonna get hurt.
16
00:00:39,460 --> 00:00:41,528
Sherlock,
I thought you were
17
00:00:41,530 --> 00:00:43,229
coming right back to...
18
00:00:43,231 --> 00:00:44,931
Oh, my God.
19
00:00:44,933 --> 00:00:47,534
Look at you.
20
00:00:47,536 --> 00:00:50,537
I didn't do any of that, did I?
21
00:00:50,539 --> 00:00:52,172
No, no, no.
22
00:00:52,174 --> 00:00:54,741
You didn't leave a scratch.
23
00:00:54,743 --> 00:00:57,844
Well, the night
is still young.
24
00:00:57,846 --> 00:01:00,046
I'll be right there.
25
00:01:02,000 --> 00:01:08,074
Watch Movies, Series & LiveTV
www.flixify.app
26
00:01:15,095 --> 00:01:16,830
Hey.
27
00:01:16,832 --> 00:01:18,798
If I went downstairs
to get a coffee, would I be...
28
00:01:18,800 --> 00:01:20,266
No, my guest
left hours ago.
29
00:01:20,268 --> 00:01:21,968
Oh. Good.
30
00:01:21,970 --> 00:01:24,037
Do I detect just
a hint of judgment?
31
00:01:24,039 --> 00:01:25,371
No, no judgment.
32
00:01:25,373 --> 00:01:27,207
A little concern, maybe.
33
00:01:27,209 --> 00:01:29,542
Well, despite what you may
have heard, no one was injured.
34
00:01:29,544 --> 00:01:31,744
I am fighting off something
of a head cold, though.
35
00:01:31,746 --> 00:01:34,280
That's not what I meant.
36
00:01:34,282 --> 00:01:36,316
There have been a lot
37
00:01:36,318 --> 00:01:39,052
of guests this week,
and I can't help but think
38
00:01:39,054 --> 00:01:41,521
that there might be
more effective ways
39
00:01:41,523 --> 00:01:44,257
to work through everything
that went down with Shinwell.
40
00:01:44,259 --> 00:01:45,992
Since everything
went down with Shinwell,
41
00:01:45,994 --> 00:01:47,493
you've cleaned
your office twice,
42
00:01:47,495 --> 00:01:48,862
you've taken
three remedial cases,
43
00:01:48,864 --> 00:01:50,597
and then you cleaned
your office again.
44
00:01:50,599 --> 00:01:54,000
So is that the picture of mental
health I should aspire to?
45
00:01:54,002 --> 00:01:55,668
Well, the captain
hasn't had anything
46
00:01:55,670 --> 00:01:57,270
you've deemed interesting
this week,
47
00:01:57,272 --> 00:01:58,905
so I know myself.
48
00:01:58,907 --> 00:01:59,973
I like to keep busy.
49
00:01:59,975 --> 00:02:01,774
So working is working for me.
50
00:02:01,776 --> 00:02:03,142
We misjudged a murderer;
51
00:02:03,144 --> 00:02:04,844
we let him into
our closest confidence.
52
00:02:04,846 --> 00:02:07,280
And then I betrayed our
colleagues by destroying
53
00:02:07,282 --> 00:02:09,048
evidence that would have
returned him to prison.
54
00:02:09,050 --> 00:02:11,184
And he repaid our many
kindnesses by ambushing
55
00:02:11,186 --> 00:02:12,518
and severely beating me.
56
00:02:12,520 --> 00:02:14,454
You've made peace
with all of that?
57
00:02:14,456 --> 00:02:17,023
No, I've just come to accept
that we don't have any options.
58
00:02:17,025 --> 00:02:19,058
There's no way to prove
that Shinwell is a killer,
59
00:02:19,060 --> 00:02:22,262
so unless you want to go to SBK
and out him as an informant...
60
00:02:22,264 --> 00:02:24,464
No, I'd still rather
he wipe out a street gang
61
00:02:24,466 --> 00:02:26,132
than the other way around.
62
00:02:26,134 --> 00:02:28,067
Okay, so we move on.
63
00:02:28,069 --> 00:02:30,069
I'm gonna go down
to the precinct,
64
00:02:30,071 --> 00:02:31,604
see if I can lend a hand with
whatever they're working on.
65
00:02:31,606 --> 00:02:33,006
You want to come?
No.
66
00:02:33,008 --> 00:02:35,608
Perfunctory investigation
will do me no good, Watson.
67
00:02:35,610 --> 00:02:37,377
To clean out the cobwebs,
68
00:02:37,379 --> 00:02:39,445
I need something
truly stimulating.
69
00:02:53,327 --> 00:02:57,196
First up,
Mr. Gary Kalajian.
70
00:02:59,600 --> 00:03:02,802
Marco, did you pull
a shift this weekend?
71
00:03:02,804 --> 00:03:06,673
We were closed. Why?
72
00:03:08,042 --> 00:03:11,377
When I closed on Friday,
this cremator was clean.
73
00:03:15,349 --> 00:03:16,649
Oh, my God.
74
00:03:23,991 --> 00:03:25,892
Call the police.
75
00:03:27,695 --> 00:03:31,030
Now.
76
00:03:31,032 --> 00:03:32,765
What should I tell them?
77
00:03:32,767 --> 00:03:36,536
Tell them somebody
got burned alive here.
78
00:03:39,940 --> 00:03:43,940
♪ Elementary 5x19 ♪
High Heat
Original Air Date on April 9, 2017
79
00:03:43,964 --> 00:03:50,764
== sync, corrected by elderman ==
@elder_man
80
00:04:05,615 --> 00:04:08,617
It's a good thing femurs
are as thick as they are.
81
00:04:08,619 --> 00:04:10,218
The biggest bones didn't
burn down completely.
82
00:04:10,220 --> 00:04:11,920
It's the only way
I could tell that there were
83
00:04:11,922 --> 00:04:14,923
two victims stuffed
into the crematory furnace.
84
00:04:14,925 --> 00:04:17,092
Looks like both were male.
Good eye.
85
00:04:17,094 --> 00:04:18,693
You can tell by the width
of the intertrochanteric crest.
86
00:04:18,695 --> 00:04:22,097
Whoever they were,
one of them left a handprint
87
00:04:22,099 --> 00:04:23,765
just inside
the incinerator door.
88
00:04:23,767 --> 00:04:25,166
It's over eight inches long.
89
00:04:25,168 --> 00:04:26,601
He was probably tall.
90
00:04:26,603 --> 00:04:29,204
And alive when he went
into the incinerator.
91
00:04:29,206 --> 00:04:30,805
Here. Have a nightmare.
92
00:04:30,807 --> 00:04:32,674
The blood was smeared
and then cooked, so...
93
00:04:32,676 --> 00:04:34,309
No fingerprints.
94
00:04:34,311 --> 00:04:36,411
I'm guessing you would have
invited us to the scene
95
00:04:36,413 --> 00:04:37,779
if there was
something to see.
96
00:04:37,781 --> 00:04:40,448
Rear exit door was
pried open with a crowbar.
97
00:04:40,450 --> 00:04:42,517
The break-in happened
sometime over the weekend.
98
00:04:42,519 --> 00:04:44,653
The crematorium workers
all have alibis,
99
00:04:44,655 --> 00:04:46,421
and we couldn't find anybody
who works in the area
100
00:04:46,423 --> 00:04:47,756
who saw anything suspicious.
101
00:04:47,758 --> 00:04:49,290
No security cameras?
102
00:04:49,292 --> 00:04:51,660
The owner says
they create privacy issues.
103
00:04:51,662 --> 00:04:53,695
We got nothing.
104
00:04:53,697 --> 00:04:54,963
Only if you don't count
105
00:04:54,965 --> 00:04:57,999
two piles of dust,
teeth and bone fragments.
106
00:04:58,001 --> 00:04:59,234
And whatever these are.
107
00:04:59,236 --> 00:05:00,969
Those were found
at the back of the incinerator,
108
00:05:00,971 --> 00:05:02,971
near where the taller
John Doe's feet were.
109
00:05:02,973 --> 00:05:05,140
I'm pretty sure they were
an orthopedic brace
110
00:05:05,142 --> 00:05:06,141
that melted down.
111
00:05:06,143 --> 00:05:08,877
Uh, something
like this.
112
00:05:09,945 --> 00:05:11,646
We should check with
Missing Persons,
113
00:05:11,648 --> 00:05:14,249
see if anyone's been
reported who wears one.
114
00:05:14,251 --> 00:05:17,352
We should also start calling
dentists in Dongan Hills.
115
00:05:17,354 --> 00:05:18,653
If I'm right about this,
116
00:05:18,655 --> 00:05:21,122
we need to locate
the dental records
117
00:05:21,124 --> 00:05:22,824
of one Frederick Kirby,
118
00:05:22,826 --> 00:05:26,161
and see if we get a match
for that gold tooth.
119
00:05:26,163 --> 00:05:28,029
Are you saying
you know one of these guys?
120
00:05:28,031 --> 00:05:29,431
After a fashion.
121
00:05:29,433 --> 00:05:31,166
Mr. Kirby was likely
122
00:05:31,168 --> 00:05:34,235
the worst private investigator
in New York City.
123
00:05:40,377 --> 00:05:42,077
Well, it's official.
124
00:05:42,079 --> 00:05:44,379
Captain just got the call.
125
00:05:44,381 --> 00:05:46,848
The gold incisor
and a couple of the molars
126
00:05:46,850 --> 00:05:48,216
and the smaller pile of ash
127
00:05:48,218 --> 00:05:49,651
match Fred Kirby's
dental records.
128
00:05:49,653 --> 00:05:51,820
Which means it took you
all of ten minutes
129
00:05:51,822 --> 00:05:54,255
to identify a John Doe
who'd been burnt to powder.
130
00:05:54,257 --> 00:05:56,825
That's got to be a record.
No, it was nothing.
131
00:05:56,827 --> 00:05:58,059
How many men do you know
proudly wear
132
00:05:58,061 --> 00:05:59,794
a high school class ring?
133
00:05:59,796 --> 00:06:01,763
Uh, you never told us
how you knew him.
134
00:06:01,765 --> 00:06:04,966
He came by the brownstone once,
accused me of poaching.
135
00:06:04,968 --> 00:06:07,469
You stole one of his clients?
136
00:06:07,471 --> 00:06:09,871
No, I was cornered by
a dissatisfied customer of his.
137
00:06:09,873 --> 00:06:11,806
I took one look
at Mr. Kirby's files,
138
00:06:11,808 --> 00:06:13,241
solved the case
on the spot.
139
00:06:13,243 --> 00:06:15,477
I've never seen such
shoddy detective work.
140
00:06:16,847 --> 00:06:18,413
This place is
a temple of incompetence.
141
00:06:18,415 --> 00:06:20,081
According to
the captain,
142
00:06:20,083 --> 00:06:22,751
this guy's one employee
is missing, too.
143
00:06:22,753 --> 00:06:25,220
The name's Lamont Wallace,
but he goes by "Pinky""
144
00:06:25,222 --> 00:06:27,589
Started driving for Fred
a couple years ago
145
00:06:27,591 --> 00:06:29,691
when Fred's eyes
started to go.
146
00:06:29,693 --> 00:06:32,994
A legally blind private eye.
No comment.
147
00:06:32,996 --> 00:06:34,562
No one's been
able to get
148
00:06:34,564 --> 00:06:36,898
either of them on the phone
for two days.
149
00:06:36,900 --> 00:06:38,533
Well, Lamont's a big guy.
150
00:06:38,535 --> 00:06:41,102
Could have been his handprint
in the incinerator.
151
00:06:41,104 --> 00:06:42,937
Yeah, maybe he and Fred
took on a dangerous case
152
00:06:42,939 --> 00:06:44,139
that got them both killed.
153
00:06:45,775 --> 00:06:47,776
You got something?
154
00:06:47,778 --> 00:06:51,613
There's almost a dozen
restraining orders here.
155
00:06:55,451 --> 00:06:59,053
These are all filed
within days of each other.
156
00:06:59,055 --> 00:07:01,556
Yeah, none of the complainants
have the same last name,
157
00:07:01,558 --> 00:07:03,625
but it's got to be a
coordinated effort, right?
158
00:07:03,627 --> 00:07:05,360
You'd think.
159
00:07:05,362 --> 00:07:08,563
Question is: what's the
link between these people?
160
00:07:08,565 --> 00:07:10,331
Tragedy.
161
00:07:11,967 --> 00:07:14,369
I assume you're familiar
with the shooting spree
162
00:07:14,371 --> 00:07:17,071
that occurred at
the Bennett Courthouse in 1987?
163
00:07:17,073 --> 00:07:19,107
Guy shoots a bunch
of brand-new citizens
164
00:07:19,109 --> 00:07:20,875
after a swearing-in ceremony.
165
00:07:20,877 --> 00:07:22,911
His wife was their
civics teacher, right?
166
00:07:22,913 --> 00:07:25,446
Four people dead,
six more wounded,
167
00:07:25,448 --> 00:07:27,882
and the shooter ended up
taking his own life.
168
00:07:27,884 --> 00:07:30,285
It was a tragedy, not a mystery.
169
00:07:30,287 --> 00:07:32,921
So what's it got to do
with a detective and his buddy
170
00:07:32,923 --> 00:07:35,023
getting burnt alive
30 years later?
171
00:07:35,025 --> 00:07:36,491
In Fred Kirby's office,
172
00:07:36,493 --> 00:07:38,459
we found multiple
restraining orders against him.
173
00:07:38,461 --> 00:07:41,229
All of them were filed by
family members of the victims
174
00:07:41,231 --> 00:07:42,564
of the courthouse shooting.
175
00:07:42,566 --> 00:07:44,265
It appears that Mr. Kirby
reached out
176
00:07:44,267 --> 00:07:47,335
to anyone tangentially
associated with the shooting.
177
00:07:47,337 --> 00:07:49,470
To what end, we don't know.
178
00:07:49,472 --> 00:07:51,306
You talk to any
of these people yet?
179
00:07:51,308 --> 00:07:54,609
No. Watson's on her way
to speak to Virginia Spivey.
180
00:07:54,611 --> 00:07:57,478
She was married to the hero
bailiff who charged the gunman.
181
00:07:57,480 --> 00:07:59,981
Took a bullet that
day, but survived.
182
00:07:59,983 --> 00:08:02,350
Unfortunately, he died
of lymphoma last year.
183
00:08:02,352 --> 00:08:05,620
Virginia Spivey was
the first one to file.
184
00:08:05,622 --> 00:08:08,056
You think papering him
with Orders of Protection
185
00:08:08,058 --> 00:08:09,624
was her idea?
That's the hope.
186
00:08:09,626 --> 00:08:11,726
If she was in touch
with all of these people,
187
00:08:11,728 --> 00:08:14,529
perhaps she'll be able to tell
us if any of them would have
188
00:08:14,531 --> 00:08:17,699
been likely to have cremated
Fred Kirby and his helper.
189
00:08:17,701 --> 00:08:19,067
In the meantime, Marcus and I
190
00:08:19,069 --> 00:08:20,668
are going to visit
the Bennett Courthouse.
191
00:08:20,670 --> 00:08:22,971
Why? The shooting happened
decades ago.
192
00:08:22,973 --> 00:08:24,606
What do you think
you're gonna find?
193
00:08:24,608 --> 00:08:27,709
This was in
Fred's office.
194
00:08:29,945 --> 00:08:32,046
Court employee badge.
195
00:08:32,048 --> 00:08:33,248
It's a sloppy forgery.
196
00:08:33,250 --> 00:08:35,016
I'm going to
chalk up the alias
197
00:08:35,018 --> 00:08:37,018
to his overheated sense
of whimsy.
198
00:08:37,020 --> 00:08:38,553
But I would
like to know
199
00:08:38,555 --> 00:08:39,754
why he deemed it necessary
200
00:08:39,756 --> 00:08:42,257
to go undercover
at the courthouse.
201
00:08:44,026 --> 00:08:45,927
Mr. Holmes.
202
00:08:45,929 --> 00:08:48,062
Louis Garmendia.
203
00:08:48,064 --> 00:08:52,433
I wish it wasn't such a sad
occasion that we got together.
204
00:08:52,435 --> 00:08:55,136
But it is an honor
to finally meet you.
205
00:08:55,138 --> 00:08:56,385
You know me?
206
00:08:56,409 --> 00:08:57,873
Of course. I'm
Louis Garmendia.
207
00:08:57,874 --> 00:09:01,042
President of the New York
Order of Private Investigators.
208
00:09:01,044 --> 00:09:04,279
Oh, the silver star
people-- NYOOPI.
209
00:09:04,281 --> 00:09:05,713
Yeah, that's us.
210
00:09:05,715 --> 00:09:08,449
So, are you responsible
for their, uh,
211
00:09:08,451 --> 00:09:10,551
rise in prominence?
212
00:09:10,553 --> 00:09:12,553
Well, I don't know if I can
really take credit for that.
213
00:09:12,555 --> 00:09:13,888
I just took over.
214
00:09:13,890 --> 00:09:15,957
But that is how I knew Fred.
215
00:09:15,959 --> 00:09:17,659
And, obviously,
we're all broken up
216
00:09:17,661 --> 00:09:19,160
over what happened to him.
217
00:09:19,162 --> 00:09:20,662
Mm.
Anyway,
218
00:09:20,664 --> 00:09:22,797
as president,
I just wanted to come down
219
00:09:22,799 --> 00:09:25,566
and let you know you've got
the association's full support.
220
00:09:25,568 --> 00:09:28,102
Anything you
or the department needs,
221
00:09:28,104 --> 00:09:29,370
you say the word.
222
00:09:29,372 --> 00:09:31,039
All right, well, I'll be sure
to pass that along.
223
00:09:31,041 --> 00:09:34,742
Main reason I came down
is to say thank you.
224
00:09:34,744 --> 00:09:38,112
Means a lot to have one of our
own working this thing for Fred.
225
00:09:38,114 --> 00:09:40,014
Sorry, one of your own?
226
00:09:40,016 --> 00:09:41,282
NYOOPI members.
227
00:09:41,284 --> 00:09:42,717
You and your partner.
228
00:09:42,719 --> 00:09:45,386
Feels right
keeping it in the family.
229
00:09:45,388 --> 00:09:49,757
Remind me, how long have
we been in the family?
230
00:09:49,759 --> 00:09:52,026
So, Houston, you were a pitcher?
231
00:09:52,028 --> 00:09:53,294
He still is.
232
00:09:53,296 --> 00:09:55,997
Lowest ERA in
Division II.
233
00:09:55,999 --> 00:09:57,298
You know
St. Cassius College?
234
00:09:57,300 --> 00:09:59,167
You should come see
us play sometime.
235
00:09:59,169 --> 00:10:01,936
Did you not hear her tell my mom
she's with the police?
236
00:10:01,938 --> 00:10:04,238
What, police
don't like baseball?
237
00:10:04,240 --> 00:10:06,941
All right, guys,
that's the rest.
238
00:10:06,943 --> 00:10:08,476
Everything's okay, right?
239
00:10:08,478 --> 00:10:11,479
Everything's fine.
I'm just here to talk.
240
00:10:11,481 --> 00:10:12,914
You two drive safe.
241
00:10:12,916 --> 00:10:14,482
Thanks, Mrs. Spivey.
242
00:10:14,484 --> 00:10:17,318
Very nice meeting you.
243
00:10:19,054 --> 00:10:20,922
Sorry about that.
244
00:10:20,924 --> 00:10:23,257
But you said you wanted to talk
about the courthouse shooting,
245
00:10:23,259 --> 00:10:25,259
and it seemed like
I should get the boys
246
00:10:25,261 --> 00:10:27,462
on their way first.
Of course.
247
00:10:27,464 --> 00:10:29,530
I was just wondering about
some of the contact
248
00:10:29,532 --> 00:10:32,000
you might have had recently with
the other victims' families.
249
00:10:32,002 --> 00:10:33,901
I've had a lot, actually.
250
00:10:33,903 --> 00:10:35,136
More than usual.
251
00:10:35,138 --> 00:10:37,472
The 30th anniversary
was last month,
252
00:10:37,474 --> 00:10:40,174
and, uh, well, you can probably
tell I like remembrances.
253
00:10:40,176 --> 00:10:41,642
We raised a
little money
254
00:10:41,644 --> 00:10:44,379
and did a memorial exhibit
at the courthouse.
255
00:10:44,381 --> 00:10:45,780
Something to make sure
256
00:10:45,782 --> 00:10:47,582
the people who died
aren't forgotten.
257
00:10:48,584 --> 00:10:49,684
Well, here.
258
00:10:49,686 --> 00:10:52,620
I was... I was gonna frame this.
259
00:10:55,290 --> 00:10:58,226
Looks like you did
some great work.
260
00:10:58,228 --> 00:11:00,661
I wanted to do it years ago,
but Gordon, my husband,
261
00:11:00,663 --> 00:11:01,863
he wouldn't have it.
262
00:11:01,865 --> 00:11:04,165
He passed away
last year,
263
00:11:04,167 --> 00:11:07,201
so now he can't object
to being remembered as a hero.
264
00:11:07,203 --> 00:11:08,536
Which he was.
265
00:11:08,538 --> 00:11:10,271
If he hadn't charged
the shooter,
266
00:11:10,273 --> 00:11:11,906
well, let's just say
267
00:11:11,908 --> 00:11:14,208
that would've been
a much bigger memorial.
268
00:11:14,210 --> 00:11:17,912
Am I correct that you
and some of the other families
269
00:11:17,914 --> 00:11:21,049
filed restraining orders
against a man named Fred Kirby?
270
00:11:21,051 --> 00:11:23,651
Yeah.
He was bothering all of us.
271
00:11:23,653 --> 00:11:25,553
Said he was trying
to put together
272
00:11:25,555 --> 00:11:27,488
his own exhibit, or something.
273
00:11:27,490 --> 00:11:29,090
His story kept changing.
274
00:11:29,092 --> 00:11:32,226
It was weird, so I got a lawyer
to shut him down.
275
00:11:32,228 --> 00:11:34,495
And I told the others
to do the same.
276
00:11:34,497 --> 00:11:35,830
Is that why you're here?
277
00:11:35,832 --> 00:11:37,899
Has he done
something illegal?
278
00:11:37,901 --> 00:11:40,001
He died this past weekend.
279
00:11:40,003 --> 00:11:42,437
Uh, more specifically,
he was murdered.
280
00:11:42,439 --> 00:11:43,738
Oh, my God.
281
00:11:43,740 --> 00:11:45,373
You think one of us...?
282
00:11:45,375 --> 00:11:47,642
I'm just curious. Is it possible
that any of the people
283
00:11:47,644 --> 00:11:49,310
he was harassing might've been
angry enough to...
284
00:11:49,312 --> 00:11:51,245
Uh, no. No, not a chance.
285
00:11:51,247 --> 00:11:53,014
He wasn't harassing anyone,
286
00:11:53,016 --> 00:11:56,484
he just wanted stuff
that belonged to the victims.
287
00:11:56,486 --> 00:11:58,219
We think he was a collector,
288
00:11:58,221 --> 00:11:59,220
or maybe a dealer.
289
00:11:59,222 --> 00:12:00,488
A dealer?
290
00:12:00,490 --> 00:12:02,490
You ever heard the term
"murderabilia"?
291
00:12:03,030 --> 00:12:04,963
People buy and sell
292
00:12:04,965 --> 00:12:07,165
I guess you'd
call them artifacts
293
00:12:07,167 --> 00:12:10,769
that connect back
to famous murders or tragedies.
294
00:12:10,771 --> 00:12:12,604
It's pretty sick.
295
00:12:12,606 --> 00:12:15,474
We just thought Fred
was trying to make a buck.
296
00:12:15,476 --> 00:12:17,509
He should've been ashamed
of himself.
297
00:12:17,511 --> 00:12:19,111
But trust me.
298
00:12:19,113 --> 00:12:21,980
None of us
would've killed the guy.
299
00:12:23,984 --> 00:12:25,817
Hey. I'm home.
300
00:12:31,491 --> 00:12:33,291
What do you think?
301
00:12:33,293 --> 00:12:35,594
I think there's a bus bench
302
00:12:35,596 --> 00:12:38,296
with my picture on it
in the library.
303
00:12:38,298 --> 00:12:40,065
I used
Fred Kirby's guy.
304
00:12:40,067 --> 00:12:42,034
It was a rush job,
so it wasn't cheap,
305
00:12:42,036 --> 00:12:43,702
but he threw in
the bench for free.
306
00:12:43,704 --> 00:12:46,738
So are you gonna tell me
what this is about, or...?
307
00:12:46,740 --> 00:12:48,407
NYOOPI.
308
00:12:49,375 --> 00:12:52,177
N-Y-O-O-P-I,
309
00:12:52,179 --> 00:12:55,614
the absurd acronym for an even
more absurd organization--
310
00:12:55,616 --> 00:12:57,916
one which counts us both
as members in good standing.
311
00:12:57,918 --> 00:12:59,518
Oh, yeah.
312
00:12:59,520 --> 00:13:00,819
The detective thing.
313
00:13:00,821 --> 00:13:03,021
Yeah, "the detective thing."
314
00:13:03,023 --> 00:13:05,323
I don't get it.
315
00:13:05,325 --> 00:13:07,359
Are you angry
because I signed us up?
316
00:13:07,361 --> 00:13:08,960
So you don't deny it.
317
00:13:08,962 --> 00:13:11,263
Yeah, it was years ago.
You'd gone back to London.
318
00:13:11,265 --> 00:13:12,864
When you came back, I added you.
319
00:13:12,866 --> 00:13:14,399
It's free advertising.
320
00:13:14,401 --> 00:13:16,268
They put us on
the "Find a Detective" page
321
00:13:16,270 --> 00:13:17,436
on their Web site.
322
00:13:17,438 --> 00:13:18,503
That is precisely the problem:
323
00:13:18,505 --> 00:13:20,038
I do not care
for the association.
324
00:13:20,040 --> 00:13:21,106
Why?
325
00:13:21,108 --> 00:13:22,808
Because the group is a sham.
326
00:13:22,810 --> 00:13:24,910
They've completely usurped
the New York State
327
00:13:24,912 --> 00:13:26,678
Division of Licensing Services
328
00:13:26,680 --> 00:13:29,748
and destroyed all semblance
of standards in our profession.
329
00:13:29,750 --> 00:13:31,416
What are you talking about?
330
00:13:31,418 --> 00:13:33,685
Once upon a time,
every aspiring P.I.
331
00:13:33,687 --> 00:13:36,254
had to take an exam
administered by the state.
332
00:13:36,256 --> 00:13:38,457
It wasn't terribly difficult,
but it was something.
333
00:13:38,459 --> 00:13:41,993
It was a barrier to entry
to keep the riffraff out.
334
00:13:41,995 --> 00:13:43,328
Now Internet searches
have become
335
00:13:43,330 --> 00:13:45,731
the primary arbiter of
legitimacy in every profession.
336
00:13:45,733 --> 00:13:47,866
So this... this star
337
00:13:47,868 --> 00:13:50,569
is all you need
to be a detective in New York.
338
00:13:50,571 --> 00:13:55,207
For $278 in annual fees,
anyone can advertise using this,
339
00:13:55,209 --> 00:13:57,609
and gain access to NYOOPI's
all-important Web site.
340
00:13:57,611 --> 00:14:00,045
So here, have your pick.
341
00:14:00,047 --> 00:14:03,582
Disgraced FBI agents,
idiots off the street, me.
342
00:14:03,584 --> 00:14:06,785
We are all equal
in the eyes of this group.
343
00:14:08,621 --> 00:14:10,122
You're being a snob.
344
00:14:10,124 --> 00:14:11,857
Someone has to be.
345
00:14:11,859 --> 00:14:13,391
Did you get my
text earlier,
346
00:14:13,393 --> 00:14:15,160
about why Fred Kirby
might have been harassing
347
00:14:15,162 --> 00:14:16,762
Virginia Spivey and the others?
348
00:14:16,764 --> 00:14:17,932
I did.
349
00:14:17,956 --> 00:14:19,771
Well, I spent the
afternoon online,
350
00:14:19,772 --> 00:14:21,434
looking at
murderabilia auctions.
351
00:14:21,435 --> 00:14:24,703
I didn't see anything there on
the Bennett Courthouse shooting.
352
00:14:24,705 --> 00:14:27,439
So I also looked at
Kirby's financials.
353
00:14:27,441 --> 00:14:29,407
It didn't look like he ever sold
that kind of stuff,
354
00:14:29,409 --> 00:14:31,910
so it makes me wonder why he was
so interested in what happened.
355
00:14:31,912 --> 00:14:33,545
It's a good question.
356
00:14:33,547 --> 00:14:35,847
I might be able
to shed some light.
357
00:14:37,517 --> 00:14:39,317
In 1987,
358
00:14:39,319 --> 00:14:41,586
when new citizens were sworn in
at the Bennett Courthouse,
359
00:14:41,588 --> 00:14:43,522
it was customary to give them
pocket-sized copies
360
00:14:43,524 --> 00:14:45,991
of the Constitution.
361
00:14:45,993 --> 00:14:49,294
These were on display
at Ms. Spivey's memorial.
362
00:14:49,296 --> 00:14:51,329
I borrowed them,
along with
363
00:14:51,331 --> 00:14:53,965
this photograph of the victims
taken shortly before
364
00:14:53,967 --> 00:14:55,267
the shooting started.
365
00:14:55,269 --> 00:14:58,804
Now, this is photograph
was taken when the memorial
366
00:14:58,806 --> 00:15:00,338
first opened last month.
367
00:15:00,340 --> 00:15:02,440
Notice the blood color
and patterns
368
00:15:02,442 --> 00:15:04,209
on these Constitutions.
369
00:15:06,846 --> 00:15:08,613
These are different.
370
00:15:08,615 --> 00:15:11,016
Mm. The blood that you're
looking at is fake.
371
00:15:11,018 --> 00:15:14,486
These are reproductions.
372
00:15:14,488 --> 00:15:17,589
They are also laden with
Fred Kirby's fingerprints.
373
00:15:17,591 --> 00:15:19,291
So he swapped these
Constitutions out
374
00:15:19,293 --> 00:15:21,693
for the real ones; he got
his murderabilia after all.
375
00:15:21,695 --> 00:15:23,962
Yes, but perhaps
not to sell.
376
00:15:23,964 --> 00:15:25,997
What do you mean?
377
00:15:25,999 --> 00:15:27,933
I mean, it's possible
Fred Kirby did what he did
378
00:15:27,935 --> 00:15:29,568
because he believed
the U.S. government
379
00:15:29,570 --> 00:15:31,970
once caused a nuclear reactor
to melt down.
380
00:15:31,972 --> 00:15:33,672
Just as it's possible
381
00:15:33,674 --> 00:15:36,007
that testing his theory
resulted in his murder.
382
00:15:36,009 --> 00:15:37,509
What are you talking about?
383
00:15:37,511 --> 00:15:41,112
I'm talking, Watson,
about Chernobyl.
384
00:15:53,669 --> 00:15:56,275
On April 26, 1986,
385
00:15:56,549 --> 00:15:59,583
a test of the Chernobyl power
plant's safety system went awry,
386
00:15:59,585 --> 00:16:02,753
causing one of its
nuclear reactors to explode.
387
00:16:02,755 --> 00:16:04,955
I remember. Everyone remembers.
388
00:16:04,957 --> 00:16:07,058
The blast
and the radiation exposure
389
00:16:07,060 --> 00:16:08,392
killed dozens that day.
390
00:16:08,394 --> 00:16:10,961
Eventually, thousands more
died of cancer.
391
00:16:10,963 --> 00:16:14,031
Human error was cited
as the precipitating cause.
392
00:16:14,033 --> 00:16:17,168
The official report
did not name any names.
393
00:16:17,170 --> 00:16:19,036
But according to one theory
on the Internet,
394
00:16:19,038 --> 00:16:22,707
the fault lies with four men:
Igor Krasnaia, Roman Hubenko,
395
00:16:22,709 --> 00:16:24,975
Dmitry Perov
and Sergei Minkovski.
396
00:16:24,977 --> 00:16:26,377
Their bodies
were never recovered,
397
00:16:26,379 --> 00:16:28,846
and photographs of the men
do not exist.
398
00:16:28,848 --> 00:16:29,947
Okay.
399
00:16:29,949 --> 00:16:31,182
Conspiracy theorists
400
00:16:31,184 --> 00:16:33,384
have long believed
that these men were saboteurs,
401
00:16:33,386 --> 00:16:36,053
working at the behest
of the American government.
402
00:16:36,055 --> 00:16:38,723
In return for their crimes,
they were granted new lives
403
00:16:38,725 --> 00:16:41,392
in the United States.
404
00:16:41,394 --> 00:16:42,860
Those were the four men
that were killed
405
00:16:42,862 --> 00:16:43,961
in the Bennett Courthouse
shooting?
406
00:16:43,963 --> 00:16:45,029
That's what people think?
407
00:16:45,031 --> 00:16:46,364
I did not say "people."
408
00:16:46,366 --> 00:16:47,832
I said "conspiracy theorists."
409
00:16:47,834 --> 00:16:49,667
Proud members
of the tinfoil hat brigade.
410
00:16:49,669 --> 00:16:52,937
Now, this was the shooter;
his name is Ronald Jones.
411
00:16:52,939 --> 00:16:55,906
His victims had just taken
the oath of citizenship.
412
00:16:55,908 --> 00:16:57,241
They were Chris Corwin,
413
00:16:57,243 --> 00:17:00,911
Nick Welden, Pete Goswin
and Leo Stavo.
414
00:17:00,913 --> 00:17:03,481
But some people believe
that these were aliases
415
00:17:03,483 --> 00:17:05,549
given to them
by the American government
416
00:17:05,551 --> 00:17:08,018
before a rogue agent
wiped them out.
417
00:17:08,020 --> 00:17:09,720
You don't really
believe that, right?
418
00:17:09,722 --> 00:17:11,889
No. But it doesn't matter
what I believe.
419
00:17:11,891 --> 00:17:14,592
The question is:
did Fred Kirby believe it?
420
00:17:14,594 --> 00:17:16,427
History is full
of imbeciles
421
00:17:16,429 --> 00:17:18,362
whose outlandish theories
have got them killed,
422
00:17:18,364 --> 00:17:21,098
so perhaps he shared his with
one of the victims' loved ones,
423
00:17:21,100 --> 00:17:22,199
and they took it poorly.
424
00:17:22,201 --> 00:17:23,667
Well, talking
to loved ones
425
00:17:23,669 --> 00:17:24,935
is one thing.
426
00:17:24,937 --> 00:17:26,704
Fred Kirby was trying
to get his hands
427
00:17:26,706 --> 00:17:28,706
on the victims'
personal effects.
428
00:17:28,708 --> 00:17:30,341
He stole mini-Constitutions
with their blood on it.
429
00:17:30,343 --> 00:17:32,276
Why?
430
00:17:32,278 --> 00:17:34,845
If these men really were
nuclear saboteurs,
431
00:17:34,847 --> 00:17:37,348
then their DNA
would've been damaged.
432
00:17:37,350 --> 00:17:39,417
Traces of caesium-137
433
00:17:39,419 --> 00:17:41,986
would mark their remains
for hundreds of years.
434
00:17:41,988 --> 00:17:44,655
The question of where
a low-rent private eye would go
435
00:17:44,657 --> 00:17:47,992
to test for such a thing
is another matter entirely.
436
00:17:47,994 --> 00:17:50,127
No, it isn't.
437
00:17:50,129 --> 00:17:53,164
I think I might know
where he would go.
438
00:17:54,933 --> 00:17:58,002
Yeah, I knew Fred. He's in my
bowling league. We're friends.
439
00:17:58,870 --> 00:18:01,105
He's dead, huh?
440
00:18:01,107 --> 00:18:02,706
Fred specialized
in cheating spouses,
441
00:18:02,708 --> 00:18:04,809
the kind who leave stains
in cheap motel rooms.
442
00:18:04,811 --> 00:18:06,177
I imagine, occasionally,
443
00:18:06,179 --> 00:18:08,646
he needed you to run
a DNA sample for him.
444
00:18:08,648 --> 00:18:10,748
When I went through
Fred's financials yesterday,
445
00:18:10,750 --> 00:18:13,184
I noticed he wrote quite a few
checks to you over the years.
446
00:18:13,186 --> 00:18:14,452
Just you.
447
00:18:14,454 --> 00:18:16,454
Never to East Rutherford
Laboratories.
448
00:18:16,456 --> 00:18:17,788
You were giving him a discount
449
00:18:17,790 --> 00:18:19,290
and pocketing
the payments yourself.
450
00:18:19,292 --> 00:18:20,958
No, that's not true.
451
00:18:20,960 --> 00:18:23,327
We also went through Fred's
phone records yesterday.
452
00:18:23,329 --> 00:18:25,362
He talked to you
six times last week.
453
00:18:25,364 --> 00:18:27,765
Can we assume it was
about the blood samples
454
00:18:27,767 --> 00:18:31,235
he wanted you to gather from
the copies of the Constitution?
455
00:18:36,442 --> 00:18:38,642
Hey, what are you doing?
456
00:18:38,644 --> 00:18:41,045
Mr. Drexel, we didn't
bring the police with us
457
00:18:41,047 --> 00:18:42,646
because we don't care about
458
00:18:42,648 --> 00:18:44,381
your minor league embezzlement.
We don't.
459
00:18:44,383 --> 00:18:46,951
It was a courtesy to you,
but it also works in our favor,
460
00:18:46,953 --> 00:18:49,019
'cause it means we can conduct
an illegal search
461
00:18:49,021 --> 00:18:50,988
for the materials
that Fred gave you.
462
00:18:50,990 --> 00:18:52,423
Yeah, I'll start
over here.
463
00:18:52,425 --> 00:18:53,924
No, don't.
464
00:18:53,926 --> 00:18:56,460
I'll give you
everything I've got, okay?
465
00:18:58,964 --> 00:19:00,431
The samples,
466
00:19:00,433 --> 00:19:02,600
the results, all of it.
467
00:19:05,837 --> 00:19:07,905
He wasn't checking
for radioactivity,
468
00:19:07,907 --> 00:19:09,840
he was running
paternity tests.
469
00:19:09,842 --> 00:19:12,510
Radioactivity? Why the hell
would I be looking for that?
470
00:19:12,512 --> 00:19:14,545
Fred didn't think that the men
who bled on these documents
471
00:19:14,547 --> 00:19:15,546
were at Chernobyl?
472
00:19:15,548 --> 00:19:17,348
No. God, no.
473
00:19:17,350 --> 00:19:18,883
He gave me that blood sample
and the four Constitutions.
474
00:19:18,885 --> 00:19:20,985
He asked me to
look for a match.
475
00:19:20,987 --> 00:19:22,686
Who's C. Gibson?
476
00:19:22,688 --> 00:19:23,888
I don't have any idea.
477
00:19:23,890 --> 00:19:25,322
I just know the guy
was looking for his father.
478
00:19:25,324 --> 00:19:27,157
But the blood on those
things wasn't viable.
479
00:19:27,159 --> 00:19:29,193
All the results came back
inconclusive.
480
00:19:29,195 --> 00:19:31,896
If you want to harass someone,
you should go find him.
481
00:19:31,898 --> 00:19:33,397
Why's that?
482
00:19:33,399 --> 00:19:35,633
Fred was nervous about
breaking the news to him.
483
00:19:35,635 --> 00:19:37,234
Said the guy had a real temper.
484
00:19:37,236 --> 00:19:38,869
I don't know.
485
00:19:38,871 --> 00:19:41,338
Maybe he's the one
who killed Fred.
486
00:19:44,442 --> 00:19:47,311
This would be a lot
easier if Fred's Kirby's system
487
00:19:47,313 --> 00:19:50,047
wasn't put stuff in files
or don't.
488
00:19:50,049 --> 00:19:52,349
Well, credit the man
for consistency.
489
00:19:52,351 --> 00:19:55,252
He was lazy and inept
in all facets of his business.
490
00:19:55,254 --> 00:19:56,654
Still, C. Gibson's
full name's got to be
491
00:19:56,656 --> 00:19:57,655
in here somewhere here, right?
492
00:19:57,657 --> 00:19:59,323
Yes, finally.
493
00:19:59,325 --> 00:20:00,524
You found it?
494
00:20:00,526 --> 00:20:03,294
Better. I found years
of annual reports
495
00:20:03,296 --> 00:20:06,297
of Fred Kirby's time
on the board of NYOOPI.
496
00:20:06,299 --> 00:20:07,798
Why would you want that?
497
00:20:07,800 --> 00:20:09,800
Because I hope to find evidence
of embezzlement or fraud.
498
00:20:09,802 --> 00:20:12,102
Let's see how many people
pay for that preposterous
499
00:20:12,104 --> 00:20:15,439
silver star when it becomes
a mark of corruption.
500
00:20:15,441 --> 00:20:16,807
NYOOPI helps people
find detectives.
501
00:20:16,809 --> 00:20:19,109
Why do you have
a problem with that?
502
00:20:19,111 --> 00:20:20,945
Because I want people
to be able to find detectives
503
00:20:20,947 --> 00:20:22,913
who've earned the right
to be called detectives.
504
00:20:22,915 --> 00:20:24,281
Well, if it were up to you,
there'd only be
505
00:20:24,283 --> 00:20:25,683
four or five people like that
in the whole world.
506
00:20:25,685 --> 00:20:27,217
Your point?
507
00:20:27,219 --> 00:20:30,454
If NYOOPI offends you so much,
why don't you just quit?
508
00:20:30,456 --> 00:20:32,790
Because then I won't be able
to pull it apart,
509
00:20:32,792 --> 00:20:34,458
piece by piece, from the inside.
510
00:20:34,460 --> 00:20:36,260
Has it ever occurred to you
511
00:20:36,262 --> 00:20:38,262
that all this righteous
indignation has less to do
512
00:20:38,264 --> 00:20:40,331
with a bunch of private eyes
supporting each other,
513
00:20:40,333 --> 00:20:41,899
and more to do with Shinwell?
514
00:20:41,901 --> 00:20:43,934
What happened
upset you.
515
00:20:43,936 --> 00:20:45,769
And despite a string of
meaningless sexual conquests,
516
00:20:45,771 --> 00:20:47,938
you're still upset,
so now you're gonna take it out
517
00:20:47,940 --> 00:20:50,474
on a bunch of
less talented detectives.
518
00:20:50,476 --> 00:20:52,109
My motives are irrelevant.
519
00:20:52,111 --> 00:20:54,845
NYOOPI is the lowest form
of fake credentialism
520
00:20:54,847 --> 00:20:56,447
and it ought not to exist.
521
00:20:56,449 --> 00:20:58,148
And by the time I'm finished,
it won't.
522
00:20:58,150 --> 00:20:59,516
Where are you going?
523
00:20:59,518 --> 00:21:02,019
The "C" in C. Gibson
stood for Carter.
524
00:21:02,021 --> 00:21:04,121
I found his name and address
ten minutes ago.
525
00:21:04,123 --> 00:21:05,990
I just lingered
to look for these.
526
00:21:09,027 --> 00:21:10,961
Here's your tea.
527
00:21:10,963 --> 00:21:14,031
Two lumps. Now you got
to tell me what's up.
528
00:21:14,033 --> 00:21:18,235
Thanks. So, our victims, Fred
Kirby and the missing driver,
529
00:21:18,237 --> 00:21:20,371
were working for a man
named Carter Gibson.
530
00:21:20,373 --> 00:21:23,007
Now, I could not find
a link between that name
531
00:21:23,009 --> 00:21:24,642
and the Bennett Courthouse
shooting,
532
00:21:24,644 --> 00:21:27,011
but that's because
Gibson's name is made-up. See?
533
00:21:27,013 --> 00:21:29,246
Carter Gibson was
534
00:21:29,248 --> 00:21:32,082
Carter Dunwitty until
he changed his name in 2007.
535
00:21:32,084 --> 00:21:34,051
Rita Dunwitty was
one of the survivors
536
00:21:34,053 --> 00:21:35,819
of the shooting in '87.
537
00:21:35,821 --> 00:21:39,089
More than that, she was married
to the shooter, Ronald Jones.
538
00:21:39,091 --> 00:21:41,025
Right.
539
00:21:41,027 --> 00:21:42,526
So, he was Carter's father.
540
00:21:42,528 --> 00:21:44,094
As far as
the world knew, yes,
541
00:21:44,096 --> 00:21:46,764
but Carter was convinced
that Ronald Jones, the shooter,
542
00:21:46,766 --> 00:21:48,298
was not his father.
543
00:21:48,300 --> 00:21:50,834
So, he hired Fred Kirby
to run paternity tests
544
00:21:50,836 --> 00:21:52,870
for the four men
who were killed in '87,
545
00:21:52,872 --> 00:21:54,638
but none of them panned out.
546
00:21:54,640 --> 00:21:57,808
Sounds like
wishful thinking, right?
547
00:21:57,810 --> 00:22:00,044
I mean, this is a guy
who changes his name
548
00:22:00,046 --> 00:22:01,945
to climb out of
his family tree.
549
00:22:01,947 --> 00:22:04,014
Can you blame him?
550
00:22:04,016 --> 00:22:05,849
Looks like Carter
551
00:22:05,851 --> 00:22:07,184
has some problems of his own.
552
00:22:07,186 --> 00:22:08,352
Disorderly conduct
553
00:22:08,354 --> 00:22:10,354
and resisting,
misdemeanor assault.
554
00:22:10,356 --> 00:22:11,655
It's a nickel-and-dime sheet,
555
00:22:11,657 --> 00:22:13,223
but he obviously has
a violent streak.
556
00:22:13,225 --> 00:22:16,360
Well, if Carter Gibson
is Ronald Jones's son,
557
00:22:16,362 --> 00:22:19,063
he may just be a chip
off the crazy old block.
558
00:22:19,065 --> 00:22:21,865
I wonder how Carter took
the news when Fred Kirby
559
00:22:21,867 --> 00:22:23,734
couldn't identify the dad
he was hoping for.
560
00:22:23,736 --> 00:22:26,270
Well, you're not the first
person to wonder that.
561
00:22:26,272 --> 00:22:28,338
Sherlock and the captain
took a couple of uniforms
562
00:22:28,340 --> 00:22:29,973
over to his house.
563
00:22:31,843 --> 00:22:34,912
Actually, they say they need us
over there right away.
564
00:22:54,999 --> 00:22:57,000
Quite a mess.
565
00:22:57,002 --> 00:22:58,502
We knocked. No one answered.
566
00:22:58,504 --> 00:23:00,070
Building manager let us in.
567
00:23:00,072 --> 00:23:03,240
Got a pile of mail,
trash is ripe--
568
00:23:03,242 --> 00:23:06,543
doesn't look like Carter
Gibson's been home in days.
569
00:23:06,545 --> 00:23:09,813
Let me guess, we're thinking
he got into some kind of scrap
570
00:23:09,815 --> 00:23:12,483
with Fred Kirby
and Pinky Wallace right here.
571
00:23:12,485 --> 00:23:13,617
Carter won,
572
00:23:13,619 --> 00:23:15,285
he cremated them,
went on the run.
573
00:23:15,287 --> 00:23:17,955
I just put his photo out
to everyone in the field.
574
00:23:17,957 --> 00:23:20,657
Captain, if you would.
575
00:23:22,594 --> 00:23:26,163
We need to revise our theory
of the crime that occurred
576
00:23:26,165 --> 00:23:27,498
in the next room.
577
00:23:27,500 --> 00:23:29,399
I don't think
578
00:23:29,401 --> 00:23:31,735
Carter Gibson was
the perpetrator, after all.
579
00:23:31,737 --> 00:23:33,337
What am I missing?
580
00:23:33,339 --> 00:23:34,772
Metal rods were mixed in
581
00:23:34,774 --> 00:23:36,640
with the cremains
in the incinerator.
582
00:23:36,642 --> 00:23:37,841
They're identical
to the ones
583
00:23:37,843 --> 00:23:39,810
in this orthopedic brace.
584
00:23:39,812 --> 00:23:41,411
Gibson had a gammy foot.
585
00:23:41,413 --> 00:23:43,614
You can see in that
photograph over there.
586
00:23:43,616 --> 00:23:44,882
Now, one could argue
that he threw
587
00:23:44,884 --> 00:23:46,416
one of his braces
into the incinerator
588
00:23:46,418 --> 00:23:48,418
to trick us, to make us think
that he was dead,
589
00:23:48,420 --> 00:23:50,521
but if he did that,
why wouldn't he throw in
590
00:23:50,523 --> 00:23:52,055
that watch, as well?
591
00:23:52,057 --> 00:23:54,191
It's inscribed with his
original name on the back.
592
00:23:54,193 --> 00:23:55,659
And if he's a man on the run,
593
00:23:55,661 --> 00:23:58,662
why didn't he take
his medication with him?
594
00:23:58,664 --> 00:24:01,465
So, the second Vic
was Pinky Wallace.
595
00:24:01,467 --> 00:24:03,467
We thought it was him
because he was tall.
596
00:24:03,469 --> 00:24:06,136
But this is size 14, and
according to Carter's sheet,
597
00:24:06,138 --> 00:24:07,604
he's six-three.
598
00:24:07,606 --> 00:24:09,773
You think half the
blood out there is his?
599
00:24:09,775 --> 00:24:12,776
Just as I think that's his
handprint in the incinerator.
600
00:24:13,945 --> 00:24:16,847
I think he was the one
who was burned alive.
601
00:24:27,531 --> 00:24:29,231
You guys find something?
602
00:24:29,233 --> 00:24:31,766
Killer left some
partial footprints.
603
00:24:32,123 --> 00:24:33,990
They stop right here,
so you got to figure
604
00:24:33,992 --> 00:24:35,692
this is where he loaded
Fred Kirby
605
00:24:35,694 --> 00:24:37,560
and Carter Gibson's bodies
into a vehicle.
606
00:24:37,562 --> 00:24:38,995
Pinky Wallace,
607
00:24:38,997 --> 00:24:40,163
Fred Kirby's driver, disappeared
608
00:24:40,165 --> 00:24:41,831
around the same time
that Fred did.
609
00:24:41,833 --> 00:24:43,333
So, he might be our guy, right?
610
00:24:43,335 --> 00:24:44,868
Well, you'd think so,
only he isn't.
611
00:24:44,870 --> 00:24:46,169
Finest Message
on him checked out
612
00:24:46,171 --> 00:24:47,704
while you were talking
to the neighbor.
613
00:24:47,706 --> 00:24:48,738
Is he dead, too?
614
00:24:48,740 --> 00:24:50,273
No, but he came close.
615
00:24:50,275 --> 00:24:53,009
He's been in the ICU at
St. Bede's for a week.
616
00:24:53,011 --> 00:24:55,211
Checked himself in
with a 104-degree fever.
617
00:24:55,213 --> 00:24:56,646
He was delirious.
618
00:24:56,648 --> 00:24:59,082
Told the nurses his name
was Lando Calrissian.
619
00:24:59,084 --> 00:25:00,783
That's why we
couldn't find him.
620
00:25:00,785 --> 00:25:03,186
He's got a long recovery from
meningitis ahead of him,
621
00:25:03,188 --> 00:25:04,354
but no prison time.
622
00:25:04,356 --> 00:25:06,990
How'd it go on your end?
623
00:25:06,992 --> 00:25:09,392
Not great. The night that
Fred Kirby disappeared,
624
00:25:09,394 --> 00:25:11,294
nobody saw anything.
625
00:25:11,296 --> 00:25:15,365
So, a few people heard
a loud bang around midnight.
626
00:25:15,367 --> 00:25:17,033
So, whatever happened here,
627
00:25:17,035 --> 00:25:19,002
maybe they finished it
with a gun.
628
00:25:19,004 --> 00:25:21,404
Anybody find any
slugs or casings?
629
00:25:21,406 --> 00:25:23,106
No, and they won't.
630
00:25:23,108 --> 00:25:26,209
I can't explain your bang,
but this was no shooting.
631
00:25:26,211 --> 00:25:27,644
As you can see
632
00:25:27,646 --> 00:25:31,014
from the blood splatter
on the walls and the ceiling,
633
00:25:31,016 --> 00:25:33,616
it's not the misty spray that
you'd associate with a gunshot.
634
00:25:33,618 --> 00:25:35,251
The droplets are round.
635
00:25:35,253 --> 00:25:36,452
They vary in size.
636
00:25:36,454 --> 00:25:37,787
The killer used a blunt object.
637
00:25:37,789 --> 00:25:40,056
Uh, I think I might even
know which one.
638
00:25:40,891 --> 00:25:42,492
As you can see here,
639
00:25:42,494 --> 00:25:46,496
Carter Gibson has
twice been honored
640
00:25:46,498 --> 00:25:49,365
by the New York
Charcot-Marie-Tooth Coalition.
641
00:25:49,367 --> 00:25:51,200
Recipients of
642
00:25:51,202 --> 00:25:53,403
the Connecting
My Talents Award receive
643
00:25:53,405 --> 00:25:55,405
a commemorative marble orb.
644
00:25:55,407 --> 00:25:57,540
What's a tooth coalition?
645
00:25:57,542 --> 00:26:00,543
Tooth is a surname,
as are Charcot and Marie.
646
00:26:00,545 --> 00:26:02,211
They're the doctors
who first described
647
00:26:02,213 --> 00:26:03,546
the neurological disorder
648
00:26:03,548 --> 00:26:06,482
which is now
more commonly known as CMT.
649
00:26:06,484 --> 00:26:09,786
CMT attacks
the peripheral nervous system,
650
00:26:09,788 --> 00:26:11,487
arms, legs, hands and feet.
651
00:26:11,489 --> 00:26:14,223
It's degenerative and the
symptoms get worse over time.
652
00:26:14,225 --> 00:26:17,126
Now, if Carter Gibson had it,
it would explain
653
00:26:17,128 --> 00:26:18,461
the orthopedic braces
654
00:26:18,463 --> 00:26:20,897
and probably the medications
he was taking.
655
00:26:20,899 --> 00:26:23,566
So, Carter raised money
and awareness for his disease
656
00:26:23,568 --> 00:26:26,302
and the coalition
gave him one of those.
657
00:26:26,304 --> 00:26:27,337
They gave him two.
658
00:26:27,339 --> 00:26:28,771
These photographs tell us
659
00:26:28,773 --> 00:26:32,608
that he received the award
in 2013 and 2015.
660
00:26:32,610 --> 00:26:35,545
The older one is missing.
661
00:26:35,547 --> 00:26:37,513
And you think it's because
the killer took it with him
662
00:26:37,515 --> 00:26:39,549
after he used it to
bash two skulls in?
663
00:26:39,551 --> 00:26:42,552
He grabbed it there
and started swinging?
664
00:26:42,554 --> 00:26:45,088
The blood evidence
would indicate that.
665
00:26:45,090 --> 00:26:48,391
An arcing motion
like this...
666
00:26:50,428 --> 00:26:53,196
...would result in
blood splatter like that.
667
00:26:53,198 --> 00:26:57,066
So, now we know how the mess
was made, but who made it?
668
00:26:58,502 --> 00:27:00,870
How's it going?
669
00:27:00,872 --> 00:27:03,606
Slowly, but we think
we figured out the real reason
670
00:27:03,608 --> 00:27:06,275
that Carter Gibson was looking
for his biological father.
671
00:27:06,277 --> 00:27:09,178
I just got off the phone
with Leonard Jones,
672
00:27:09,180 --> 00:27:10,646
Ronald Jones's father.
673
00:27:10,648 --> 00:27:11,814
I was calling
to notify him
674
00:27:11,816 --> 00:27:12,982
that we think his
grandson, Carter,
675
00:27:12,984 --> 00:27:14,250
was the victim
of a homicide.
676
00:27:14,252 --> 00:27:16,119
He didn't take
it too hard.
677
00:27:16,121 --> 00:27:18,321
Apparently, they'd been
estranged most of Carter's life.
678
00:27:18,323 --> 00:27:20,356
That changed
earlier this year.
679
00:27:20,358 --> 00:27:21,991
Carter's CMT was getting worse.
680
00:27:21,993 --> 00:27:24,794
The disease is inherited
and the symptoms tend to follow
681
00:27:24,796 --> 00:27:26,396
a similar course
within families.
682
00:27:26,398 --> 00:27:28,431
Now, no one on
his mother's side had it,
683
00:27:28,433 --> 00:27:30,166
so Carter reached out
to his paternal grandfather
684
00:27:30,168 --> 00:27:32,201
to find out
what he could expect.
685
00:27:32,203 --> 00:27:35,338
Thing is, there was no CMT on
that side of the family, either.
686
00:27:35,340 --> 00:27:37,907
- How is that possible?
- 30 years ago,
687
00:27:37,909 --> 00:27:40,376
no one really knew why Ronald
Jones shot up the courthouse
688
00:27:40,378 --> 00:27:41,644
where his wife worked,
689
00:27:41,646 --> 00:27:44,080
but Grandpa Leonard
always had a sneaking suspicion.
690
00:27:44,082 --> 00:27:47,450
Ronald had figured out
he wasn't Carter's real dad.
691
00:27:47,452 --> 00:27:49,485
That would explain some things,
like why the four people
692
00:27:49,487 --> 00:27:51,521
he killed and the six
he wounded were all men.
693
00:27:51,523 --> 00:27:53,823
He thought one of them
was sleeping with his wife.
694
00:27:53,825 --> 00:27:55,358
It's an old secret,
695
00:27:55,360 --> 00:27:58,161
but maybe someone figured
it was still worth killing over.
696
00:27:58,163 --> 00:27:59,729
We were just
about to call the relatives
697
00:27:59,731 --> 00:28:01,164
of the people who filed
restraining orders
698
00:28:01,166 --> 00:28:02,498
against Fred Kirby,
699
00:28:02,500 --> 00:28:04,233
see if any of them
had CMT.
700
00:28:04,235 --> 00:28:05,868
Just tread lightly.
701
00:28:05,870 --> 00:28:08,404
If one of them did this,
we don't want to tip them.
702
00:28:11,442 --> 00:28:13,009
Mr. Garmendia.
703
00:28:13,011 --> 00:28:15,011
Sorry to stop by
unannounced like this,
704
00:28:15,013 --> 00:28:16,646
but your address
is in our files.
705
00:28:16,648 --> 00:28:18,514
If you're looking for an update
on the investigation
706
00:28:18,516 --> 00:28:20,516
of Fred Kirby's murder,
I'm afraid I can't help you.
707
00:28:20,518 --> 00:28:21,918
There have been
some developments,
708
00:28:21,920 --> 00:28:23,486
but they need
to remain confidential.
709
00:28:23,488 --> 00:28:24,954
I don't want an update.
710
00:28:24,956 --> 00:28:28,658
I'm here to talk to you,
detective to detective.
711
00:28:32,930 --> 00:28:37,333
I know you broke into
NYOOPI's computer today.
712
00:28:37,335 --> 00:28:39,902
Someone used
Fred Kirby's old log-in
713
00:28:39,904 --> 00:28:43,072
from an I.P. address
inside the NYPD,
714
00:28:43,074 --> 00:28:44,207
and then they downloaded
715
00:28:44,209 --> 00:28:47,610
a bunch of our
tax records.
716
00:28:47,612 --> 00:28:50,513
I could tell you didn't
like us when we met.
717
00:28:50,515 --> 00:28:53,249
Got the feeling
we embarrass you.
718
00:28:53,251 --> 00:28:56,085
You want to tell me
what you're up to?
719
00:28:56,087 --> 00:28:57,520
It's quite simple, really.
720
00:28:57,522 --> 00:28:59,589
I'm going to dismantle
your organization.
721
00:28:59,591 --> 00:29:01,757
NYOOPI is a blight
722
00:29:01,759 --> 00:29:03,192
on the profession which I love.
723
00:29:03,194 --> 00:29:04,494
It enables con men and imbeciles
724
00:29:04,496 --> 00:29:06,429
to pass themselves off
as detectives.
725
00:29:06,431 --> 00:29:08,164
Your group deserves
to be exposed
726
00:29:08,166 --> 00:29:10,099
as the rubber stamp that it is.
727
00:29:10,101 --> 00:29:13,069
Would it surprise you to know
728
00:29:13,071 --> 00:29:15,471
that I agree with you
about NYOOPI?
729
00:29:15,473 --> 00:29:17,373
Hmm?
730
00:29:17,375 --> 00:29:21,644
I was an investigator
for the ATF for over 15 years
731
00:29:21,646 --> 00:29:23,279
before I went private.
732
00:29:23,281 --> 00:29:24,881
I get steamed when I see
733
00:29:24,883 --> 00:29:27,016
the kind of folks
that are advertising
734
00:29:27,018 --> 00:29:29,452
with our silver star.
735
00:29:29,454 --> 00:29:32,688
That's why I got involved,
only I don't want to destroy it.
736
00:29:32,690 --> 00:29:34,457
I want to turn it around.
737
00:29:34,459 --> 00:29:36,726
We're offering
training seminars now.
738
00:29:36,728 --> 00:29:39,095
We just launched a message board
739
00:29:39,097 --> 00:29:41,564
where people can
crowdsource their cases.
740
00:29:43,066 --> 00:29:44,834
I want NYOOPI
to help its members
741
00:29:44,836 --> 00:29:46,736
be better at what they do.
742
00:29:46,738 --> 00:29:48,504
Your members want to be better?
743
00:29:48,506 --> 00:29:49,839
A lot of them mean well.
744
00:29:49,841 --> 00:29:51,207
That's not what I asked.
745
00:29:51,209 --> 00:29:52,542
How many of them
are attending your classes?
746
00:29:52,544 --> 00:29:53,976
How many are on
the message board?
747
00:29:53,978 --> 00:29:56,279
All I'm asking for
is a little more time.
748
00:29:56,281 --> 00:29:57,647
NYOOPI's had decades.
749
00:29:57,649 --> 00:29:59,215
Not with me they haven't.
750
00:29:59,217 --> 00:30:02,885
Look, Mr. Holmes,
this-this thing we do,
751
00:30:02,887 --> 00:30:04,520
this job, it's important.
752
00:30:04,522 --> 00:30:07,456
Now, you say you don't like
a lot of our membership.
753
00:30:07,458 --> 00:30:10,426
I get that, but at least
they're in one place now.
754
00:30:10,428 --> 00:30:12,595
NYOOPI goes away, and
they scatter in the wind.
755
00:30:12,597 --> 00:30:14,931
And I won't know if I
could've made them better.
756
00:30:14,933 --> 00:30:19,101
I won't know if I could've
kept a few from getting killed.
757
00:30:19,103 --> 00:30:21,604
Now, it's too late
for Fred Kirby,
758
00:30:21,606 --> 00:30:24,340
but it's not too late
for the rest.
759
00:30:24,342 --> 00:30:28,578
All I can promise you is that
your organization will be spared
760
00:30:28,580 --> 00:30:32,481
my full energies until I have
solved Fred Kirby's murder.
761
00:30:32,483 --> 00:30:34,383
Well, I know
how good you are,
762
00:30:34,385 --> 00:30:37,253
so I guess that doesn't
give me much time.
763
00:30:37,255 --> 00:30:40,356
Thanks for
hearing me out.
764
00:30:54,272 --> 00:30:56,706
Sherlock?
765
00:30:56,708 --> 00:30:58,741
In your bedroom.
766
00:31:04,581 --> 00:31:07,216
Hello.
767
00:31:07,218 --> 00:31:09,185
Okay, whatever this is,
768
00:31:09,187 --> 00:31:11,254
does it really need
to be happening in my bedroom?
769
00:31:11,256 --> 00:31:14,190
This is helping me determine
how much force was used
770
00:31:14,192 --> 00:31:17,026
to beat Carter Gibson
and Fred Kirby to death.
771
00:31:17,028 --> 00:31:18,861
I didn't think you'd mind.
772
00:31:18,863 --> 00:31:21,380
Okay, so, you've already
made one miscalculation.
773
00:31:21,381 --> 00:31:23,648
So, how is the rest
of your math going?
774
00:31:23,650 --> 00:31:26,350
Take this.
775
00:31:26,352 --> 00:31:28,686
Yeah.
776
00:31:28,688 --> 00:31:32,189
That spatter pattern
I've painted in black there,
777
00:31:32,191 --> 00:31:36,193
how far is it from Mr. Coconut?
778
00:31:39,297 --> 00:31:42,500
17 feet, seven inches.
779
00:31:42,502 --> 00:31:46,237
That is precisely the distance
that blood and viscera traveled
780
00:31:46,239 --> 00:31:48,406
from the bookcase
to the far wall
781
00:31:48,408 --> 00:31:51,375
at the murder scene
in Carter Gibson's apartment.
782
00:31:51,377 --> 00:31:54,078
Okay, so why did you think
to check that?
783
00:31:54,080 --> 00:31:56,280
Because it is one of the most
distant blood spatters
784
00:31:56,282 --> 00:31:57,782
I've ever encountered.
785
00:31:57,784 --> 00:31:59,984
So distant, in fact,
that efforts to recreate it
786
00:31:59,986 --> 00:32:02,987
with my own arms
have fallen decidedly short.
787
00:32:02,989 --> 00:32:05,256
Maybe you need a stronger arm.
788
00:32:05,258 --> 00:32:07,191
Between an adolescence
spent at the cricket ground
789
00:32:07,193 --> 00:32:09,093
and two decades training
in the combat arts,
790
00:32:09,095 --> 00:32:11,429
my arm strength
is a little above average.
791
00:32:12,464 --> 00:32:14,999
Now, this tropical drupe
is filled with
792
00:32:15,001 --> 00:32:17,001
a synthetic blood
of my own design.
793
00:32:17,003 --> 00:32:19,537
And I'm gonna murder it...
794
00:32:19,539 --> 00:32:21,405
with a candlepin bowling ball,
795
00:32:21,407 --> 00:32:22,840
which is almost
identical in size
796
00:32:22,842 --> 00:32:25,576
and weight to the marble award
that was used.
797
00:32:46,698 --> 00:32:48,232
Not even close.
798
00:32:48,234 --> 00:32:51,335
My best effort,
when my arms were still fresh,
799
00:32:51,337 --> 00:32:54,939
created a blood spatter
which reached 14.3 feet.
800
00:32:54,941 --> 00:32:57,341
Okay, so...
801
00:32:57,343 --> 00:33:00,778
our killer is a contestant
in the world's strongest man?
802
00:33:00,780 --> 00:33:02,446
Not quite.
803
00:33:02,448 --> 00:33:05,716
This experiment has shown
that creating that pattern
804
00:33:05,718 --> 00:33:07,284
requires power
805
00:33:07,286 --> 00:33:09,019
and form.
806
00:33:09,021 --> 00:33:11,182
The force and motion required
to create the spatter pattern
807
00:33:11,182 --> 00:33:13,549
at Carter Gibson's apartment
are commensurate with
808
00:33:13,551 --> 00:33:15,818
throwing a 98 mile-an-hour
fastball.
809
00:33:15,820 --> 00:33:18,387
That's major league heat.
810
00:33:18,389 --> 00:33:20,957
Yeah, which is precisely
why our killer
811
00:33:20,959 --> 00:33:24,060
is on the verge of making
major league millions.
812
00:33:24,062 --> 00:33:26,562
You told me about him
the other day.
813
00:33:28,632 --> 00:33:30,967
You think I look
like this Carter guy?
814
00:33:30,969 --> 00:33:33,102
A little.
815
00:33:33,104 --> 00:33:35,238
You both have
your father's ears.
816
00:33:35,240 --> 00:33:37,974
Your dad had an affair
with Rita Dunwitty.
817
00:33:37,976 --> 00:33:39,542
Carter's mom.
818
00:33:39,544 --> 00:33:40,877
He was your
half-brother.
819
00:33:40,879 --> 00:33:42,645
Now, you can deny it
if you want,
820
00:33:42,647 --> 00:33:45,681
but we're gonna order
a DNA test to confirm.
821
00:33:48,085 --> 00:33:50,553
I don't believe anything
you're saying.
822
00:33:50,555 --> 00:33:53,122
But, if it's true, so what?
823
00:33:53,124 --> 00:33:54,757
It's why you
killed him.
824
00:33:54,759 --> 00:33:56,125
Along with the
detective he hired
825
00:33:56,127 --> 00:33:57,693
to find his
real father.
826
00:33:57,695 --> 00:33:59,395
Carter grew up
thinking that his father
827
00:33:59,397 --> 00:34:01,297
was a mass shooter.
828
00:34:01,299 --> 00:34:03,466
It followed him around
like a dark cloud.
829
00:34:03,468 --> 00:34:05,268
We think that Fred Kirby
uncovered evidence
830
00:34:05,270 --> 00:34:06,502
of the affair.
831
00:34:06,504 --> 00:34:07,904
Now, if we're right,
832
00:34:07,906 --> 00:34:09,672
and Carter could prove
that his real father
833
00:34:09,674 --> 00:34:12,141
was actually the hero
who stopped the shooting,
834
00:34:12,143 --> 00:34:14,443
he probably couldn't wait
to tell the world.
835
00:34:14,445 --> 00:34:17,113
That was gonna be a real problem
for you, wasn't it?
836
00:34:17,115 --> 00:34:20,116
I have no idea
what you're talking about.
837
00:34:20,118 --> 00:34:22,084
We're talking about CMT.
838
00:34:22,086 --> 00:34:23,352
What?
839
00:34:23,354 --> 00:34:25,221
Charcot-Marie-Tooth
disease.
840
00:34:25,223 --> 00:34:27,323
It's a genetic
neuromuscular disorder.
841
00:34:27,325 --> 00:34:28,858
Carter had it.
842
00:34:28,860 --> 00:34:30,626
And given that it's
passed down paternally,
843
00:34:30,628 --> 00:34:32,328
we're guessing that you do, too.
844
00:34:32,330 --> 00:34:34,597
You knew that if anyone
discovered you had it,
845
00:34:34,599 --> 00:34:36,899
your plans of making millions
as a major league pitcher
846
00:34:36,901 --> 00:34:38,367
would be wiped out.
847
00:34:38,369 --> 00:34:40,836
Uh, we can't
imagine a team offering
848
00:34:40,838 --> 00:34:43,239
a big contract to someone
who could wake up one morning
849
00:34:43,241 --> 00:34:46,242
and suddenly lose all feeling
in his throwing arm.
850
00:34:46,244 --> 00:34:48,811
If a well-known CMT
advocate like Carter
851
00:34:48,813 --> 00:34:51,013
shared the news about
finding his real family,
852
00:34:51,015 --> 00:34:53,783
say if he put it out
on social media,
853
00:34:53,785 --> 00:34:55,885
it would've been a matter
of time before someone
854
00:34:55,887 --> 00:34:57,186
put two and two together.
855
00:34:57,188 --> 00:34:59,055
Now, you needed
the whole thing to go away
856
00:34:59,057 --> 00:35:00,756
so you could still cash in.
857
00:35:00,758 --> 00:35:02,058
You guys are crazy.
858
00:35:02,060 --> 00:35:03,826
Forget CMT, look at my ERA.
859
00:35:03,828 --> 00:35:06,262
I'm pitching great; I-I don't
have a muscle disorder.
860
00:35:06,264 --> 00:35:07,797
All right, then,
let's talk about something
861
00:35:07,799 --> 00:35:09,365
you definitely don't have:
862
00:35:09,367 --> 00:35:11,367
an alibi for the night
of the murders.
863
00:35:11,369 --> 00:35:13,603
That's because you were
at Carter's apartment.
864
00:35:13,605 --> 00:35:16,439
He and Fred were telling you
things you didn't want to hear,
865
00:35:16,441 --> 00:35:19,108
so you took Carter's award
down from the shelf,
866
00:35:19,110 --> 00:35:20,810
and you killed them with it.
867
00:35:20,812 --> 00:35:23,179
Only a matter of time
until we find it.
868
00:35:23,181 --> 00:35:26,949
Got to think it'll have your
fingerprints on it when we do.
869
00:35:29,786 --> 00:35:31,020
I need you two.
870
00:35:31,022 --> 00:35:32,688
Now.
871
00:35:40,163 --> 00:35:41,397
What's going on?
872
00:35:41,399 --> 00:35:43,099
He was about to
give it up.
873
00:35:43,101 --> 00:35:45,568
Well, that would've been
a real problem for the D.A.
874
00:35:45,570 --> 00:35:47,069
How so?
875
00:35:47,071 --> 00:35:48,904
That's Paul Fontino.
876
00:35:48,906 --> 00:35:51,307
He's Houston's pitching coach.
877
00:35:51,309 --> 00:35:53,542
He just confessed
to both murders.
878
00:36:07,799 --> 00:36:10,200
Sorry about the wait,
Mr. Fontino.
879
00:36:11,095 --> 00:36:13,495
We just had to confirm
there really were bloodstains
880
00:36:13,497 --> 00:36:15,130
in the trunk of your car.
881
00:36:15,132 --> 00:36:18,300
Don't know why you'd think
I'd lie about such a thing.
882
00:36:18,302 --> 00:36:19,954
Maybe because
we can't quite figure out
883
00:36:19,955 --> 00:36:22,055
why you would do such a thing.
884
00:36:22,057 --> 00:36:24,791
You've had two parking
tickets in the last 20 years.
885
00:36:24,793 --> 00:36:25,993
But this past weekend,
886
00:36:25,995 --> 00:36:27,527
you just snap?
887
00:36:27,529 --> 00:36:29,296
Murder two people?
888
00:36:29,298 --> 00:36:33,567
I've been working with
Houston Spivey for six years.
889
00:36:33,569 --> 00:36:37,704
Found him when he was a skinny
little high school sophomore.
890
00:36:37,706 --> 00:36:39,673
He's a good kid.
891
00:36:39,675 --> 00:36:41,575
He's got a hell
of a future.
892
00:36:41,577 --> 00:36:43,610
I didn't want to see it wasted.
893
00:36:43,612 --> 00:36:45,545
What does that mean?
Last week,
894
00:36:45,547 --> 00:36:49,216
he tells me this Carter guy
and his crazy P.I.,
895
00:36:49,218 --> 00:36:51,118
they're after him
for a blood test.
896
00:36:51,120 --> 00:36:53,487
Well, he told us he'd
never seen Carter Gibson
897
00:36:53,489 --> 00:36:54,821
before in his life.
898
00:36:54,823 --> 00:36:57,290
You ever been
21 years old before?
899
00:36:57,292 --> 00:36:58,725
Kid's scared.
900
00:36:59,727 --> 00:37:01,728
I mean, if you think
Houston asked me to do this,
901
00:37:01,730 --> 00:37:03,130
you got the wrong idea.
902
00:37:03,132 --> 00:37:04,765
He wanted to pay them.
903
00:37:04,767 --> 00:37:07,434
He asked me for the money.
What money?
904
00:37:07,436 --> 00:37:10,437
They were extorting him; they
wanted $50,000 to keep quiet.
905
00:37:10,439 --> 00:37:12,506
And they thought Houston,
a college student,
906
00:37:12,508 --> 00:37:14,441
would have 50 grand
lying around?
907
00:37:14,443 --> 00:37:16,476
I'm sure they figured that
a future first rounder
908
00:37:16,478 --> 00:37:18,779
would be able to
get his hands on some money
909
00:37:18,781 --> 00:37:20,213
if he really wanted it.
910
00:37:20,215 --> 00:37:21,748
He probably could've.
911
00:37:21,750 --> 00:37:23,717
But I didn't think
it was right.
912
00:37:23,719 --> 00:37:25,752
I told Houston I'd handle it.
913
00:37:25,754 --> 00:37:28,188
So you set up a meeting?
914
00:37:28,190 --> 00:37:29,523
At Carter's apartment.
915
00:37:29,525 --> 00:37:32,092
I thought I'd rant
and rave a little
916
00:37:32,094 --> 00:37:34,661
and get them to back off.
917
00:37:34,663 --> 00:37:36,063
But they weren't budging.
918
00:37:36,065 --> 00:37:37,464
I saw red,
919
00:37:37,466 --> 00:37:39,299
grabbed this...
920
00:37:39,301 --> 00:37:44,337
marble statue thing
off from the shelf...
921
00:37:44,339 --> 00:37:46,106
that was that.
922
00:37:47,809 --> 00:37:49,342
Well, he's lying obviously.
923
00:37:49,344 --> 00:37:51,178
I mean, it's a tale
as old as time.
924
00:37:51,180 --> 00:37:53,113
Or at least as old
as professional sports.
925
00:37:53,115 --> 00:37:55,082
The sins of the entitled athlete
926
00:37:55,084 --> 00:37:57,384
being swept under the rug
by his enablers.
927
00:37:57,386 --> 00:37:59,219
I'm sure
Mr. Fontino's family
928
00:37:59,221 --> 00:38:02,022
will be enjoying
the blood money he's earning
929
00:38:02,024 --> 00:38:04,958
as soon as Houston Spivey's name
is called in the draft.
930
00:38:04,960 --> 00:38:07,094
Well, the lab says the blood
in Fontino's trunk
931
00:38:07,096 --> 00:38:08,462
was a match for the victims.
932
00:38:08,464 --> 00:38:10,297
And he knew about
the murder weapon.
933
00:38:10,299 --> 00:38:12,966
He knew about it, couldn't
produce it though, could he?
934
00:38:12,968 --> 00:38:15,402
He said he threw it off
the Staten Island Ferry.
935
00:38:15,404 --> 00:38:17,237
Yeah, another lie, no doubt.
936
00:38:17,239 --> 00:38:20,273
Look, I'll concede that he was
an accessory after the fact.
937
00:38:20,275 --> 00:38:21,475
I don't think
there's any coincidence
938
00:38:21,477 --> 00:38:22,709
that the bodies
were disposed of
939
00:38:22,711 --> 00:38:24,444
at his cousin's crematorium,
940
00:38:24,446 --> 00:38:27,447
but I refuse to believe
he's our killer.
941
00:38:27,449 --> 00:38:29,015
Then should've come
with me to the precinct
942
00:38:29,017 --> 00:38:30,884
instead of trying to dig up
more dirt on NYOOPI.
943
00:38:30,886 --> 00:38:32,953
Yes, I should have.
944
00:38:32,955 --> 00:38:34,521
Found what I need, though.
945
00:38:34,523 --> 00:38:36,590
What do you mean?
I mean,
946
00:38:36,592 --> 00:38:40,527
this time tomorrow,
NYOOPI will be no more.
947
00:38:40,529 --> 00:38:44,231
For what it's worth,
Fontino was a college pitcher.
948
00:38:44,233 --> 00:38:46,433
Yes, he was.
That was 45 years ago.
949
00:38:46,435 --> 00:38:48,568
Now he's a retiree
with a herniated disc
950
00:38:48,570 --> 00:38:50,237
and arthritis in both hands.
951
00:38:50,239 --> 00:38:52,305
I mean, he'd have trouble
lifting the murder weapon
952
00:38:52,307 --> 00:38:54,341
above his head, let alone
swinging it hard enough
953
00:38:54,343 --> 00:38:55,575
to send blood flying
954
00:38:55,577 --> 00:38:57,177
across the room.
955
00:39:00,448 --> 00:39:02,115
That was the sound.
956
00:39:02,117 --> 00:39:03,617
What?
957
00:39:03,619 --> 00:39:04,951
A bang.
958
00:39:04,953 --> 00:39:06,753
Carter's neighbors said
they heard a noise that night,
959
00:39:06,755 --> 00:39:09,456
a bang.
960
00:39:11,959 --> 00:39:14,060
Thanks for coming
in, Mr. Spivey.
961
00:39:14,062 --> 00:39:15,929
I don't understand
why I'm here again.
962
00:39:15,931 --> 00:39:17,364
When I gave my statement
about Coach Fontino,
963
00:39:17,366 --> 00:39:19,032
my lawyer said that would be it.
964
00:39:19,034 --> 00:39:20,667
He's right,
you don't have to say
965
00:39:20,669 --> 00:39:21,935
anything today.
966
00:39:21,937 --> 00:39:23,470
I'm just curious,
um, do you know
967
00:39:23,472 --> 00:39:25,572
what the worst pitch
you ever threw was?
968
00:39:25,574 --> 00:39:29,376
Uh, gave up a two-run double
in the playoffs last year.
969
00:39:29,378 --> 00:39:30,877
Hung a curve.
970
00:39:30,879 --> 00:39:32,145
Actually,
971
00:39:32,147 --> 00:39:33,947
it was when you
flung the murder weapon
972
00:39:33,949 --> 00:39:37,317
from the scene of the
double homicide you committed.
973
00:39:40,698 --> 00:39:42,471
Two of
Carter Gibson's neighbors
974
00:39:42,472 --> 00:39:45,940
heard a bang like that the night
he and Fred Kirby were killed.
975
00:39:45,942 --> 00:39:47,842
They thought it was
a car backfiring.
976
00:39:47,844 --> 00:39:49,110
We wondered if maybe
977
00:39:49,112 --> 00:39:51,179
it was a gunshot.
978
00:39:51,181 --> 00:39:53,447
Turns out, it was the sound
of a perfect strike.
979
00:39:53,449 --> 00:39:54,782
You left tracks
980
00:39:54,784 --> 00:39:56,551
at the scene.
981
00:39:56,553 --> 00:39:59,120
Bloody footprints
from Carter's door
982
00:39:59,122 --> 00:40:01,255
to your coach's car.
983
00:40:01,257 --> 00:40:03,124
Stood to reason
you took the murder weapon
984
00:40:03,126 --> 00:40:05,860
along with the bodies.
985
00:40:05,862 --> 00:40:07,094
Only you didn't.
986
00:40:07,096 --> 00:40:09,163
You threw it 245 feet
987
00:40:09,165 --> 00:40:10,765
into that Dumpster.
988
00:40:10,767 --> 00:40:12,166
It's pretty impressive.
989
00:40:12,168 --> 00:40:15,136
But like I said, it was
the worst pitch of your life.
990
00:40:15,138 --> 00:40:17,738
The blood of both victims
and your fingerprints
991
00:40:17,740 --> 00:40:19,106
are all over it.
992
00:40:19,108 --> 00:40:20,441
What happened?
993
00:40:20,443 --> 00:40:22,276
Did you think
you heard someone coming?
994
00:40:22,278 --> 00:40:25,079
You panicked, threw it
as far as you could?
995
00:40:29,251 --> 00:40:32,987
I'd like my lawyer now, please.
996
00:40:36,325 --> 00:40:38,392
Sherlock?
997
00:40:39,316 --> 00:40:40,468
Is that why
you called me down here,
998
00:40:40,469 --> 00:40:44,004
to troll me again for
enrolling us in NYOOPI?
999
00:40:44,006 --> 00:40:46,273
Gonna mark you down a point
for poor observational skills.
1000
00:40:46,275 --> 00:40:47,474
Look more closely.
1001
00:40:48,943 --> 00:40:51,011
"ESOOPI"?
1002
00:40:51,013 --> 00:40:53,880
I spoke to NYOOPI President
Louis Garmendia this morning.
1003
00:40:53,882 --> 00:40:55,348
He has agreed to shutter
the organization,
1004
00:40:55,350 --> 00:40:57,384
as I predicted
he would.
1005
00:40:57,386 --> 00:41:00,854
But, like a phoenix
rising from the dung heap,
1006
00:41:00,856 --> 00:41:03,957
a new trade organization has
been born to take its place:
1007
00:41:03,959 --> 00:41:05,826
ESOOPI.
1008
00:41:05,828 --> 00:41:08,195
The Empire State Order
of Private Investigators.
1009
00:41:08,197 --> 00:41:10,030
All members of
the former NYOOPI
1010
00:41:10,032 --> 00:41:11,631
will be allowed
to stay on.
1011
00:41:11,633 --> 00:41:13,600
And Mr. Garmendia will be
retaining his position
1012
00:41:13,602 --> 00:41:15,001
as president.
1013
00:41:15,003 --> 00:41:16,636
Is that what you meant
when you said
1014
00:41:16,638 --> 00:41:18,004
NYOOPI would be no more?
1015
00:41:18,006 --> 00:41:19,506
So what's the point?
1016
00:41:19,508 --> 00:41:21,241
Now there's a group
that's gonna be handing out
1017
00:41:21,243 --> 00:41:23,076
gold stars
instead of silver ones?
1018
00:41:23,078 --> 00:41:26,046
No. Nothing will be handed out.
1019
00:41:26,048 --> 00:41:28,715
Gold stars and a listing on the
group's all-important Web site
1020
00:41:28,717 --> 00:41:30,217
will be earned
1021
00:41:30,219 --> 00:41:33,220
by members who complete a
course of my own design.
1022
00:41:33,222 --> 00:41:35,889
It's compulsory, not optional.
1023
00:41:35,891 --> 00:41:37,891
You really think
1,200 dues-paying members
1024
00:41:37,893 --> 00:41:39,793
are gonna sit still
for that?
1025
00:41:39,795 --> 00:41:41,962
I don't believe they're
gonna have a choice.
1026
00:41:41,964 --> 00:41:43,363
I spent all of yesterday
1027
00:41:43,365 --> 00:41:45,198
poring over the bylaws
that they agreed to
1028
00:41:45,200 --> 00:41:47,601
when they joined;
NYOOPI is more than allowed
1029
00:41:47,603 --> 00:41:50,137
to change its name
and its standards.
1030
00:41:50,139 --> 00:41:51,671
And any members
that don't appreciate
1031
00:41:51,673 --> 00:41:53,306
that kind of attention to detail
1032
00:41:53,308 --> 00:41:55,008
will learn to.
1033
00:41:55,010 --> 00:41:56,843
Or they'll forfeit
their membership.
1034
00:41:56,845 --> 00:41:58,411
Is that...?
1035
00:41:58,413 --> 00:42:00,180
The test, yes.
1036
00:42:00,182 --> 00:42:02,749
I thought you would be honored
to be the first ESOOPI member
1037
00:42:02,751 --> 00:42:03,950
to attempt it.
1038
00:42:06,254 --> 00:42:08,722
"List three suitable methods
for determining the age
1039
00:42:08,724 --> 00:42:10,323
of a fecal deposit on a..."
1040
00:42:10,325 --> 00:42:11,825
This is the first question?
1041
00:42:11,827 --> 00:42:14,161
Two hours, Watson.
1042
00:42:14,163 --> 00:42:15,428
Make me proud.
1043
00:42:15,430 --> 00:42:18,865
♪
1044
00:42:18,867 --> 00:42:22,435
♪ Lurch around the room
1045
00:42:22,437 --> 00:42:24,838
♪ You know you got the right.
1046
00:42:35,958 --> 00:42:42,758
== sync, corrected by elderman ==
@elder_man
1046
00:42:43,305 --> 00:43:43,473
Watch Movies, Series & LiveTV
www.flixify.app